1 Comment

G.O.R.E. Score: Marvel Zombies Return

Marvel Zombies Return (2010)Original Release Date: January 1, 2010 (collected)
Number of Issues: 5
Publisher: Marvel Entertainment

“Marvel Zombies Return” was a mini-series designed to give readers a sense of closure for the story concerning the “original” Marvel Zombies, superheroes from an “alternate” Earth who were stricken by an alien virus and became flesh-munching monsters.  Marvel was also wise to bring in some experience “zombie veteran” writers to each have their hand at writing an issue of this series:

  • the second issue, with a story revolving around Iron Man, was written by David Wellington, author of the “Monster” trilogy of books
  • the third issue, with a story revolving around Wolverine, was written by “Patient Zero” and “Zombie CSU” author Jonathan Maberry
  • the fourth issue, with a story revolving around The Hulk, was written by Seth Grahame-Smith, best known to fans as the “co-author” of “Pride and Prejudice and Zombies”

Fred Van Lente, the writer for the “Marvel Zombies 3” and “Marvel Zombies 4” mini-series, provided the bookend first and fifth issue.

When we last saw these self-aware superhero zombies at the end of “Mrvel Zombies 2” (“MZ3″ and “MZ4″ followed a storyline of different characters), they were surprised by a small group of living survivors and teleported off of their original home world of Earth, which they had decimated.  The teleportation device used to surprise them had been reconstructed from its original form and the reader was never given an idea of who programmed it or where it was set to send the zombies.  We find out in this mini-series that the zombies were sent to “Earth-Z,” a parallel universe I believe we have never seen before, except the teleporter deposited every zombie in a different location in this universe, and it is apparently the late 1960s on “Earth-Z.”  I’m judging this date by the facts given to us in Issue #1: the story follows zombie Spider-Man as he finds himself witnessing events that took place in his home world some time ago (in issues of Spider-Man comic books first released by Marvel in 1969, according to editors notes).  His actions in this universe lead to – surprise surprise! – some carnage and devastation, and with that, the series is off and running.

Time to give Marvel Zombies the final Score:

G: General Entertainment – This story returns us to the high-enjoyability factor that we haven’t really seen since the original Marvel Zombies went away in “MZ2.”  There is an odd feeling that nagged me throughout the series, but I attribute it to the writers knowing that this was essentially the end of the line for this particular storyline, and whenever creators know that they only have a finite amount of story space left to work with, I do feel that it causes them to sometimes do things a little differently.  The story definitely gave readers a very interesting and satisfying endpoint to the tale, and for that sense of closure that not all comic stories get, I am grateful. 8/10

O: Original Content – Bringing back the original Marvel Zombies makes me smile, and I suspect I’m not the only MZ fan to do so.  We’ll go back to the original score the first mini-series’ got here, since these are the same zombies we know and love from those series. 7/10

R: Realism – A couple of nagging questions here, like why did the zombified heroes get dumped in the late ‘60s and spread across the universe?  Also, when we last saw the zombies in “MZ2,” many of them were working on controlling their hunger, and some had actually achieved control; in this series, the control (and the desire to do so) seems to come and go whenever it’s convenient for the plot line. 6/10

E: Effects and Editing – Each issue in this series got a different artist and a different artistic approach to it, which I think is really inventive.  Kudos to artist Nick Dragotta for a great first issue of this series, as the story really evoked the ‘60s/’70s comic book feel and look.  Writer Fred Van Lente also did a pretty good job with the first issue, although some of the zombie carnage felt a little out of place when paired with the “wholesome” feel of the old-school artwork.  I know I have really written about how displeased I was with Van Lente’s work in “MZ3” and “MZ4,” but perhaps he learned a thing or two about effectively writing a zombie story by working with some of the great zombie writers of our time.  Wellington and Grahame-Smith’s issues were also well written, but I feel that Maberry’s Wolverine-centric issue is really the high point of this series, both in his writing and the accompanying frenetic “sketch-style” artwork (created by Jason Shawn Alexander). 9/10

TOTAL SCORE: 7.5/10
VERDICT: SWEET

When this review was originally released here on the site in June of last year, it was the culmination of an event called “Marvel Zombies Week,” where I reviewed all seven Marvel Zombies mini-series in seven days.  As the review was originally being written, “Marvel Zombies 5” was being released, following the story and characters from “MZ3” and “MZ4,” so who’s to say another Marvel Zombies Week isn’t in our futures, somewhere down the line?  Stay tuned!

And now, my friends, you know the Score!

About these ads

One comment on “G.O.R.E. Score: Marvel Zombies Return

  1. I never really got into Marvel Zombies all that much. I got what I believe was the first one, though it has been so long I can’t even be sure, and while I love zombies and love superheroes, the combination never seemed to give me much of a warm and fuzzy feeling. I’m sure some of these stories are great if I had persisted, and I might revisit all of them since it seems that they have all wound down…but then again, it has been almost a year and a half since this was released and I haven’t done so yet. Perhaps some day! Good review as always, regardless.

Your Thoughts:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: